Parliament Chiefs Hold Meetings to Scuttle Impeachment Process
by Kim Ives (Haiti Liberte)
A second Special Commission of
Inquiry into the Jul. 13 death of Investigating Judge Jean Serge Joseph, this
one commissioned by Haiti’s Chamber of Deputies, released its report on Aug.
23, recommending that the lower house indict President Michel Martelly, Prime
Minister Laurent Lamothe, and Justice Minister Jean Renel Sanon for illegally
intervening in a judicial investigation, threatening a judge thereby causing
his death, and then publicly and repeatedly lying about the matter.
Inquiry into the Jul. 13 death of Investigating Judge Jean Serge Joseph, this
one commissioned by Haiti’s Chamber of Deputies, released its report on Aug.
23, recommending that the lower house indict President Michel Martelly, Prime
Minister Laurent Lamothe, and Justice Minister Jean Renel Sanon for illegally
intervening in a judicial investigation, threatening a judge thereby causing
his death, and then publicly and repeatedly lying about the matter.
The
findings of the report match almost exactly those of a Senate inquiry released
on Aug. 8 (see Haïti Liberté, Vol.
7, No. 5, 8/14/2013). The Senate Commission also recommended that
Parliament remove Martelly and Lamothe from office.
findings of the report match almost exactly those of a Senate inquiry released
on Aug. 8 (see Haïti Liberté, Vol.
7, No. 5, 8/14/2013). The Senate Commission also recommended that
Parliament remove Martelly and Lamothe from office.
Judge
Joseph was investigating charges of massive corruption against Martelly’s wife,
Sophia St. Rémy Martelly, and their son, Olivier Martelly. After issuing
subpoenas for several high government officials to testify before him, he had
been pressured and threatened personally by Martelly and others. Finally, in a
secret Jul. 11 meeting, Martelly, Lamothe, Sanon, and other officials told the
judge to call off the investigation, according to both parliamentary reports.
Two days later, the judge died from a brain hemorrhage caused by either stress
or poison.
Joseph was investigating charges of massive corruption against Martelly’s wife,
Sophia St. Rémy Martelly, and their son, Olivier Martelly. After issuing
subpoenas for several high government officials to testify before him, he had
been pressured and threatened personally by Martelly and others. Finally, in a
secret Jul. 11 meeting, Martelly, Lamothe, Sanon, and other officials told the
judge to call off the investigation, according to both parliamentary reports.
Two days later, the judge died from a brain hemorrhage caused by either stress
or poison.
Martelly
and Lamothe publicly claim that they had never met the judge and never attended
the meeting, which took place at the office of Martelly’s legal counselor Garry
Lissade, both reports say.
and Lamothe publicly claim that they had never met the judge and never attended
the meeting, which took place at the office of Martelly’s legal counselor Garry
Lissade, both reports say.
Whether
the lower house will act on the report has taken on urgency since the Deputies,
who under Haiti’s Constitution have the power to indict the President and Prime
Minister, are scheduled to go on vacation on Sep. 9 and would not reconvene
until Jan. 14, 2014, when Parliament is due to resume to its regular session…
maybe.
the lower house will act on the report has taken on urgency since the Deputies,
who under Haiti’s Constitution have the power to indict the President and Prime
Minister, are scheduled to go on vacation on Sep. 9 and would not reconvene
until Jan. 14, 2014, when Parliament is due to resume to its regular session…
maybe.
On
that date, another third (10 seats) of the Senate will have expired as one
third did two years earlier, thereby reducing the body of 30 to less than its
quorum and theoretically rendering Parliament non-functional.
that date, another third (10 seats) of the Senate will have expired as one
third did two years earlier, thereby reducing the body of 30 to less than its
quorum and theoretically rendering Parliament non-functional.
Parliamentary
critics have long argued that Martelly and Lamothe have purposefully delayed
holding partial Senate elections for over two years to arrive at precisely this
outcome. Some argue that remaining Senate seats won’t expire until January
2015.
critics have long argued that Martelly and Lamothe have purposefully delayed
holding partial Senate elections for over two years to arrive at precisely this
outcome. Some argue that remaining Senate seats won’t expire until January
2015.
As
shock, outrage, and disgust raced through Haiti’s body politic in the wake of
the two devastating reports, the Parliament’s two presidents, Sen. Simon
Dieuseul Desras and Dep. Jean Tholbert Alexis, convened meetings at
Pétionville’s Montana Hotel from Aug. 26-28 to meet with political parties on
day one, civil society groups on day two, and Haiti’s diplomatic corps on day
three.
shock, outrage, and disgust raced through Haiti’s body politic in the wake of
the two devastating reports, the Parliament’s two presidents, Sen. Simon
Dieuseul Desras and Dep. Jean Tholbert Alexis, convened meetings at
Pétionville’s Montana Hotel from Aug. 26-28 to meet with political parties on
day one, civil society groups on day two, and Haiti’s diplomatic corps on day
three.
“The
meetings were essentially damage control,” Sen. Moïse Jean-Charles told Haïti Liberté. “They were organized
after the Senate President’s visit to Washington, DC, where they pushed him to
do it. The meetings with political parties, civil society, and the diplomats
didn’t focus on the grave crimes detailed in two Parliamentary inquiry reports,
which are now the top priority. We can’t have a president and his new Macoutes
assassinate a judge, and we just ignore that.”
meetings were essentially damage control,” Sen. Moïse Jean-Charles told Haïti Liberté. “They were organized
after the Senate President’s visit to Washington, DC, where they pushed him to
do it. The meetings with political parties, civil society, and the diplomats
didn’t focus on the grave crimes detailed in two Parliamentary inquiry reports,
which are now the top priority. We can’t have a president and his new Macoutes
assassinate a judge, and we just ignore that.”
The
three days of meetings ended with Sen. Desras issuing a bizarre ultimatum: if
President Martelly does not show up to make his traditional address at
Parliament’s opening session on Jan. 14 – an absence which would indicate that
he considers Parliament dissolved – then Parliament would consider him as
“having resigned.” In other words, if you accept us, we’ll accept you; if you
reject us, we’ll reject you.
three days of meetings ended with Sen. Desras issuing a bizarre ultimatum: if
President Martelly does not show up to make his traditional address at
Parliament’s opening session on Jan. 14 – an absence which would indicate that
he considers Parliament dissolved – then Parliament would consider him as
“having resigned.” In other words, if you accept us, we’ll accept you; if you
reject us, we’ll reject you.
Sen.
Moïse called it a message of weakness and compromise with Martelly, “who should
be chased from power as quickly as possible.”
Moïse called it a message of weakness and compromise with Martelly, “who should
be chased from power as quickly as possible.”
Moïse’s
analysis is echoed by leading popular organizations who issued a statement on
Sep. 3, warning against “hand-me-down democracy” (demokrasi pepe) and “monkey
business” (magouy) aimed at excluding the Haitian masses from any role in
resolving the crisis.
analysis is echoed by leading popular organizations who issued a statement on
Sep. 3, warning against “hand-me-down democracy” (demokrasi pepe) and “monkey
business” (magouy) aimed at excluding the Haitian masses from any role in
resolving the crisis.
Saying
that the Martelly/Lamothe regime was guilty of a host of crimes over the past
two years and that the Parliament’s reports present “the last straw,” the
groups said that the masses were now rising up but that Washington and its
allies are using Parliament “to hold a series of dialogues with the supposedly
opposition political parties, civil society and representatives of the
diplomatic corps to impose their own solution in this political crisis.”
that the Martelly/Lamothe regime was guilty of a host of crimes over the past
two years and that the Parliament’s reports present “the last straw,” the
groups said that the masses were now rising up but that Washington and its
allies are using Parliament “to hold a series of dialogues with the supposedly
opposition political parties, civil society and representatives of the
diplomatic corps to impose their own solution in this political crisis.”
The
eight signing groups, which include the Dessalines Coordination (KOD), the
Heads Together of Popular Organizations, and the National Movement for Liberty,
Equality, and Fraternity of Haitians (MOLEGHAF), denounced that “the meetings
did not address the most important question of the moment: the two special
inquiry reports of the Parliament on the death of Judge Joseph, and how the
country can immediately replace this criminal government which has been caught
in the act of lying to the people.” Therefore the groups called on “all sectors
of good faith, who are looking for a national solution to get the country out
of the mess it is in, to force the Parliamentarians to take up their
responsibility in the face of the brazen Martelly/Lamothe regime.”
eight signing groups, which include the Dessalines Coordination (KOD), the
Heads Together of Popular Organizations, and the National Movement for Liberty,
Equality, and Fraternity of Haitians (MOLEGHAF), denounced that “the meetings
did not address the most important question of the moment: the two special
inquiry reports of the Parliament on the death of Judge Joseph, and how the
country can immediately replace this criminal government which has been caught
in the act of lying to the people.” Therefore the groups called on “all sectors
of good faith, who are looking for a national solution to get the country out
of the mess it is in, to force the Parliamentarians to take up their
responsibility in the face of the brazen Martelly/Lamothe regime.”
To
do so, according to the Haitian Constitution, the Deputies would have to vote
to indict Martelly, and the Senate would then act as a High Court of Justice to
put him on trial.
do so, according to the Haitian Constitution, the Deputies would have to vote
to indict Martelly, and the Senate would then act as a High Court of Justice to
put him on trial.
The
latest report, which was prepared by Deputies Sadrac Dieudonné, Gluck Théophile
and François Louytz Amiot, charges that Martelly and Lamothe “lied because they
know very well that the encroachment of the Executive Branch into the field of
sovereign powers of the judiciary – which they did – is arbitrary and illegal,
and therefore unacceptable, because the Constitution calls for the effective
separation of the three state powers. They lied because they know they had
exerted strong pressure on the judge, sufficient to bring on the stroke which
caused his death… For them, the best strategy is to deny that the meeting of
July 11, 2013 ever took place.”
latest report, which was prepared by Deputies Sadrac Dieudonné, Gluck Théophile
and François Louytz Amiot, charges that Martelly and Lamothe “lied because they
know very well that the encroachment of the Executive Branch into the field of
sovereign powers of the judiciary – which they did – is arbitrary and illegal,
and therefore unacceptable, because the Constitution calls for the effective
separation of the three state powers. They lied because they know they had
exerted strong pressure on the judge, sufficient to bring on the stroke which
caused his death… For them, the best strategy is to deny that the meeting of
July 11, 2013 ever took place.”
At
the end of the 26-page report, the investigating deputies “recommend
impeachment of the Head of State, Prime Minister and Minister of Justice for
perjury, a crime against the Constitution and abuse of power, that shows the
encroachment of the Executive Branch into the sovereign domain of the
Judiciary.”
the end of the 26-page report, the investigating deputies “recommend
impeachment of the Head of State, Prime Minister and Minister of Justice for
perjury, a crime against the Constitution and abuse of power, that shows the
encroachment of the Executive Branch into the sovereign domain of the
Judiciary.”
Getting
the deputies to act on the report may prove challenging. Largely through the
use of bribery, Martelly and Lamothe control a majority of the lower house
through the Parliamentary block for Stability and Progress (PSP). However, many
deputies have begun to question their allegiance to Martelly not only due to
the reports but also following his week-long unexplained departure from the
country last month. When he surfaced later in Suriname, Martelly worsened
matters by calling his parliamentary critics “dumb.”
the deputies to act on the report may prove challenging. Largely through the
use of bribery, Martelly and Lamothe control a majority of the lower house
through the Parliamentary block for Stability and Progress (PSP). However, many
deputies have begun to question their allegiance to Martelly not only due to
the reports but also following his week-long unexplained departure from the
country last month. When he surfaced later in Suriname, Martelly worsened
matters by calling his parliamentary critics “dumb.”
“Martelly
is losing deputies, so anything is possible,” Sen. Jean-Charles said.
is losing deputies, so anything is possible,” Sen. Jean-Charles said.
The
Senate, with its fragile quorum, may also pose a problem. Sen. Edo Zenny, a
close Martelly ally, told Le Nouvelliste that
“I will vote against [any impeachment] and if it is me who has to block a
quorum, I will do it.”
Senate, with its fragile quorum, may also pose a problem. Sen. Edo Zenny, a
close Martelly ally, told Le Nouvelliste that
“I will vote against [any impeachment] and if it is me who has to block a
quorum, I will do it.”
But
Pierre Espérance of the National Network to Defend Human Rights (RNDDH)
calculates that there would be enough votes in the Senate to impeach Martelly
because even Senators who sometimes support Martelly “often take a distance
from the regime’s illegal actions.”
Pierre Espérance of the National Network to Defend Human Rights (RNDDH)
calculates that there would be enough votes in the Senate to impeach Martelly
because even Senators who sometimes support Martelly “often take a distance
from the regime’s illegal actions.”
The
President has also alienated many by appointing a new hard-line Port-au-Prince
District Attorney, who threatened to crack down on journalists and dissidents.
“Playtime is over,” said Francisco René, using the same phrase uttered by
former dictator Jean-Claude “Baby Doc” Duvalier when he launched a crackdown on
critics in November 1980. “The radio dramas are over. There will no longer be
any question of characterizing the authorities any old way… Slander will be
prosecuted. I will strengthen the system of criminal justice.”
President has also alienated many by appointing a new hard-line Port-au-Prince
District Attorney, who threatened to crack down on journalists and dissidents.
“Playtime is over,” said Francisco René, using the same phrase uttered by
former dictator Jean-Claude “Baby Doc” Duvalier when he launched a crackdown on
critics in November 1980. “The radio dramas are over. There will no longer be
any question of characterizing the authorities any old way… Slander will be
prosecuted. I will strengthen the system of criminal justice.”
Meanwhile,
Haitian police arrested and severely beat the man who brought the original
lawsuit against Martelly’s wife and son that Judge Joseph was investigating
before his death. On Aug. 16, Enold Floréstal was arrested and held for two
days in an apparent domestic dispute. Afterwards, Floréstal gave an interview
to Radio Kiskeya claiming to have proof that on Jul. 10, the day before Judge
Joseph’s fateful meeting at Lissade’s office, Prime Minister Lamothe offered
him money and a diplomatic post if he would drop his case against Martelly’s
wife and son.
Haitian police arrested and severely beat the man who brought the original
lawsuit against Martelly’s wife and son that Judge Joseph was investigating
before his death. On Aug. 16, Enold Floréstal was arrested and held for two
days in an apparent domestic dispute. Afterwards, Floréstal gave an interview
to Radio Kiskeya claiming to have proof that on Jul. 10, the day before Judge
Joseph’s fateful meeting at Lissade’s office, Prime Minister Lamothe offered
him money and a diplomatic post if he would drop his case against Martelly’s
wife and son.
